Exportar Publicação
A publicação pode ser exportada nos seguintes formatos: referência da APA (American Psychological Association), referência do IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers), BibTeX e RIS.
Oruç, R., Uzelgun, M. & Sadek, K. (2023). Sequencing critical moves for ethical argumentation practice: Munāẓara and the interdependence of procedure and agent. Informal Logic. 43 (1), 113-137
R. Oruç et al., "Sequencing critical moves for ethical argumentation practice: Munāẓara and the interdependence of procedure and agent", in Informal Logic, vol. 43, no. 1, pp. 113-137, 2023
@article{oruç2023_1733302187852, author = "Oruç, R. and Uzelgun, M. and Sadek, K.", title = "Sequencing critical moves for ethical argumentation practice: Munāẓara and the interdependence of procedure and agent", journal = "Informal Logic", year = "2023", volume = "43", number = "1", doi = "10.22329/il.v43i1.7073", pages = "113-137", url = "https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/7073" }
TY - JOUR TI - Sequencing critical moves for ethical argumentation practice: Munāẓara and the interdependence of procedure and agent T2 - Informal Logic VL - 43 IS - 1 AU - Oruç, R. AU - Uzelgun, M. AU - Sadek, K. PY - 2023 SP - 113-137 SN - 2293-734X DO - 10.22329/il.v43i1.7073 UR - https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/7073 AB - The aim of this paper is to highlight an interdependence between procedural and agential norms that undermines their neat separation when appraising argumentation. Drawing on the munāẓara tradition, we carve a space for sequencing in argumentation scholarship. Focusing on the antagonist’s sequencing of critical moves, we identify each sequence’s corresponding values of argumentation: coalescence, reliability, and efficacy. These values arise through the mediation of virtues and simultaneously underpin procedural as well as agential norms. Consequently, an ambiguity between procedure and agent becomes apparent. This ambiguity hints at the potential for a virtue theory of argumentation that draws on procedural norms. ER -