Ciência_Iscte
Comunicações
Descrição Detalhada da Comunicação
Between Inclusion and Exclusion: The Role of the Welfare State in Language Learning for Asylum Seekers and Refugees in Portugal and Spain
Título Evento
IMISCOE and CIES-Iscte Workshop: Language Diversity, Education and Learning in the Context of Migration and Diaspora
Ano (publicação definitiva)
2025
Língua
Inglês
País
Portugal
Mais Informação
--
Web of Science®
Esta publicação não está indexada na Web of Science®
Scopus
Esta publicação não está indexada na Scopus
Google Scholar
Esta publicação não está indexada no Google Scholar
Esta publicação não está indexada no Overton
Abstract/Resumo
This presentation aims to address the importance of learning the host country’s language for the
social and economic inclusion of asylum seekers and refugees, as well as the barriers to this
learning process, which emerge from the very first moment of reception by the welfare state, one
increasingly absorbed by liberalization and the transfer of responsibilities to the private sphere.
This presentation is part of a broader investigation into the (in)ability of the welfare state to
welcome asylum seekers and refugees in Portugal and Spain, within the broader context of the
European Union. It is structured into three parts. The first provides a theoretical framework,
outlining the main contemporary approaches to the topic. The second characterizes the
reception systems in both countries, focusing on the responses related to language learning. The
third presents findings from a set of interviews conducted with support networks for Afghan
refugees - networks that closely accompany the integration processes of these individuals into
Portuguese and Spanish societies - as well as from participant observation carried out in a
reception centre for asylum seekers and refugees in Portugal.
Findings from the analysis of the reception systems reveal a clear gap between what is formally
planned and what is actually implemented in practice regarding language learning for asylum
seekers and refugees. This gap is reflected in the limited success of many integration programs.
Moreover, insights drawn from interviews and participant observation indicate that: language
learning opportunities within reception structures are unstable, scarce, and short-term, often
dependent on volunteer efforts, which hampers their effectiveness; and that language
acquisition is crucial for inclusion, namely, for accessing services, for entering the formal labour
market, and for navigating the system, building agency and fighting for the recognition of their
rights to access services, healthcare, adequate housing, and a regulated labour market. The lack
of language proficiency thus emerges as one of the main barriers to effective inclusion.
In conclusion, we observe a welfare state that has increasingly adopted liberalization trends,
shifting its responsibility for delivering social responses onto civil society organizations that often
lack adequate funding and operate through volunteerism or the financial capacity of private
actors. This model proves fragile and incapable of providing a form of reception that leads to
genuine inclusion. As a result, what should be a policy of socio-economic integration ends up reinforcing vulnerability and exclusion, ultimately undermining goals of inclusion and the
reconstruction of citizenship.
This contribution is highly relevant to the themes of the workshop, as it focuses on adult asylum
seekers and refugees, highlighting how access to language learning directly impacts social
inclusion and citizenship, or, conversely, reinforces exclusion. It also demonstrates how adult
asylum seekers and refugees construct agency and resistance through language learning, since
acquiring the host country’s language allows them to understand the system more effectively
and, consequently, to act upon it in an informed and emancipatory way, and to claim their rights
more effectively.
Agradecimentos/Acknowledgements
--
Palavras-chave
English