Does music training improve socio-emotional abilities? A longitudinal study with children
Event Title
International Conference IC CIPEM 2021
Year (definitive publication)
2021
Language
English
Country
Portugal
More Information
Web of Science®
This publication is not indexed in Web of Science®
Scopus
This publication is not indexed in Scopus
Google Scholar
This publication is not indexed in Google Scholar
This publication is not indexed in Overton
Abstract
There is an increasing interest in the idea that music training might improve non-musical cognitive
abilities (Jaschke et al., 2013; Sutcliffe & Ruffman, 2020). Most research relies on comparisons between musicians and non-musicians, though. It remains therefore unclear whether expertise-related differences are driven by the training itself or reflect predispositions (Moreno & Bidelman, 2014). Additionally, the main focus has been on how music training relates to language and domain-general abilities such as IQ (e.g., Moreno et al., 2009; Schellenberg et al., 2004). Whether and how music training affects socio- emotional skills has been poorly explored.
We conducted a longitudinal study with 6- to 8-year-old children to examine this question. The study was implemented in a regular school environment, and it included pre-test, training and pos-test phases, in three conditions: an experimental music training condition (Orff-based training, n = 37), an active control condition (basketball training, n = 40), and a passive control condition (no training, n = 33). None of the children had previous experience of formal music or sports training. The training programs were conducted over two school years (2019-2020, 2020-2021), consisted of group activities, and the experimental and active controls groups completed a similar number of training sessions: in the first school year, two sessions per week, lasting 90 minutes each; in the second school year, one session per week, lasting 90 minutes (in total, the groups completed ca. 114 hours of training). The measures covered cognitive, motor, music, and socio-emotional domains. Specifically, the children were assessed before and after training regarding music skills (auditory discrimination of rhythm and melodies, musical memory and rhythm copy), motor skills (fine-motor skills, gross motor skills, and coordination), global cognition (non-verbal reasoning), executive functions (auditory short-term memory, auditory working memory, and visual interference), emotion recognition in auditory (speech prosody, non-verbal vocalizations) and visual modalities (faces), and higher order socio-emotional abilities (empathy, emotion comprehension, and social functioning).
Before training, the three groups were similar across measures, and they were also similar in age, sex, laterality (handedness) and socio-economic status. In this talk we will also present longitudinal evidence for the following questions: whether music training was associated with larger improvements in emotion recognition, empathy, emotion comprehension, and social functioning, than those observed in the control groups; and whether these improvements are direct, or rather mediated by improvements in domain-general cognitive abilities, namely non-verbal reasoning, and executive functions. We will additionally examine if individual differences in musical ability before training predict the magnitude of improvements in socio-emotional abilities over time.
This study is well placed to elucidate potential associations between music training and socio- emotional abilities in children. The findings might inform debates on the use of music as an intervention tool in clinical and educational settings.
Acknowledgements
--
Keywords
Cognitive neuroscience,Socio-emotional ability,Music training,Children
Português